Since June 2019, when I opened my first report of the year, I reported 27 security vulnerabilities: 4 has been marked as duplicated, 3 as informative, 2 as not applicable, 9 have been resolved, and 9 are currently confirmed and the fix is ongoing. All these 27 vulnerabilities were reported to Gitlab.
Especially in October and November I had a lot of fun testing the implementation of ElasticSearch over Gitlab. Two of the issues I have found on this topic have already been disclosed:
- Group search leaks private MRs, code, commits
- Group search with Elastic search enable leaks unrelated data
Why just Gitlab?
I have an amazing daily job as Solutions Architect at Nextbit that I love. I am not interested in becoming a full-time security researcher, but I am having fun dedicating some hours every month in looking for securities vulnerabilities.
However, since I don’t want it to be a job, I focus on a product I know very well, also because sometimes I contribute to it and I use it daily.
I also tried to target some program I didn’t know anything about, but I get bored quite fast: to find some interesting vulnerability you need to spend quite some time to learn how the system works, and how to exploit it.
Last but not least, Gitlab nowadays manages its HackerOne program in a very cool way: they are very responsive, kind, and I like they are very transparent! You can read a lot about how their security team works in their handbook.
Can you teach me?
Since I have shared a lot of the disclosed reports on Twitter, some people came and asked me to teach them how to start in the bug bounties world. Unfortunately, I don’t have any useful suggestion: I haven’t studied on any specific resource, and all the issues I reported this year come from a deep knowledge of Gitlab, and from what I know thanks to my daily job. There are definitely more interesting people to follow on Twitter, just check over some common hashtags, such as TogetherWeHitHarder.
I am writing this blog post from my new keyboard: a custom-made WASD VP3, generously donated by Gitlab after I won a contest for their first year of public program on HackerOne. I won the best written report category, and it was a complete surprise; I am not a native English speaker, 5 years ago my English was a monstrosity (if you want to have some fun, just go reading my old blog posts), and still to this day I think is quite poor, as you can read here.
Indeed, if you have any suggestion on how to improve this text, please write me!
Congratulations to Gitlab for their first year on HackerOne, and keep up the good work! Your program rocks, and in the last months you improved a lot!
HackerOne started a new program, called HackerOne Clear, only on invitation, where they vet all researchers. I was invited and I thought about accepting the invitation. However, the scope of the data that has to be shared to be vetted is definitely too wide, and to be honest I am surprised so many people accepted the invitation. HackerOne doesn’t perform the check, but delegates to a 3rd party. This 3rd party company asks a lot of things.
I totally understand the need of background checks, and I’d be more than happy to provide my criminal record. It wouldn’t be the first time I am vetted, and I am quite sure it wouldn’t be the last.
More than the criminal record, I am a puzzled about these requirements:
- Financial history, including credit history, bankruptcy and financial judgments;
- Employment or volunteering history, including fiduciary or directorship responsibilities;
- Gap activities, including travel;
- Health information, including drug tests;
- Identity, including identifying numbers and identity documents;
Not only the scope is definitely too wide, but also all these data will be stored and processed outside EU! Personal information will be stored in the United States, Canada and Ireland. Personal information will be processed in the United States, Canada, the United Kingdom, India and the Philippines.
As European citizen who wants to protect his privacy, I cannot accept such conditions. I’ve written to HackerOne asking why such a wide scope of data, and they replied that since it’s their partner that actually collects the information, there is nothing they can do. I really hope HackerOne will require fewer data in the future, preserving privacy of their researchers.
In these days I’ve though a lot about what I want to do in my future about bug bounties, and for the 2020 I will continue as I’ve done in the last months: assessing Gitlab, dedicating not more than a few hours a month. I don’t feel ready to step up my game at the moment. I have a lot of other interests I want to pursue in 2020 (travelling, learning German, improve my cooking skills), so I will not prioritize bug bounties for the time being.
That’s all for today, and also for the 2019! It has been a lot of fun, and I wish to you all a great 2020! For any comment, feedback, critic, write to me on Twitter (@rpadovani93) or drop an email at [email protected].
- 29th December 2019: added paragraph about having asked to HackerOne more information on why they need such wide scope of personal data.